Blessed Trade

Radley Balko has an interesting piece up at Tech Central Station titled “God and Globalization." Balko’s piece looks at the “interplay between trade and religion,” and where they have taken the world in the past, the present, and could take the world in the future.

One paragraph in the piece struck me as off the mark, though.

"Any discussion of trade and globalization’s influence on religion will share many characteristics of the debate over globalization and culture. Religion, after all, is a pretty determinant factor in gleaning the identity of a given culture. Trade opponents argue that developing cultures don’t have the means to compete with overpowering western influence, and so trade and globalization have led to a kind of “Coca-Cola-fication” of places like Africa and South and Central Asia. The West moves in and imposes its culture before the developing countries in those regions ever had an opportunity to forge a culture of their own."

Specifically, what I find off the mark, are the words which I have put into bold type.  I do not necessarily think that the West “imposes” its culture on developing countries.  I think that individuals within developing countries suck up Western culture like sponges because they have been denied so much for so long.  Additionally, stating that developing countries have Western culture imposed on them prior to having “an oppotunity to forge a culture of the own,” is simply false.  Developing countries have had cultures of their own for centuries.  Its just that the cultures developed in these developing countries were extremely lacking in developing wisdom, reason, freedom and trade. 

Posted by on 03/24 at 07:00 AM

  1. Just to clarify, I don’t agree with the statement in bold, I was merely paraphrasing the arguments of trade opponents.

    Posted by Radley Balko  on  03/24  at  07:53 AM

  2. Thanks for clarifying that Radley.

    Posted by  on  03/24  at  08:15 AM

  3. I’ve yet to decipher what “globalization” means beyond free trade. “Globalization” sounds suspiciously like a government program.

    I’ve asked Radley about the distinction and he says globalization includes the cultural influences beyond trade. I fail to see how cultural influences are beyond trade.

    I also note that globalists produce reams of legislation and treaties, confirming my suspicion about it being a government program.

    There is only one thing any state can do to advance free trade: Stop interfering with it!

    Is that globalization? 

    Posted by John T. Kennedy  on  03/24  at  01:50 PM

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Smileys

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below:


Next entry: A Note from the Dog

Previous entry: If the Palestinians Are Weeds, The Israelis Are A Spray Bottle of Roundup

<< Back to main