Abdicated Reasoning and Common Sense

Schools’ zero tolerance rules have a tendency to relieve teachers and administrators from utilizing their reasoning skills, and their common sense. 

While I can understand sending a kid packing if he, or she for that matter, carries a handgun into a school, some of the other reasons schools send kids packing, or enact draconian punishments for, as part of their zero tolerance policies, border on the absurd.

Writing “I love Alex” on a school gymnasium wall brought a 12-year-old the same punishment as if she had made terrorist threats.

The Katy Independent School District rated the message, written with a baby blue marker by sixth-grader Shelby Sendelbach, as a Level 4 infraction — the same as for threats, drug possession and assault.

Only murder, gun possession, sexual assault and arson are considered more severe by the suburban Houston district.

Young Miss Sendelbach’s parents are fighting back against the school, and I wish them success, but they also appear to be disconnected from their reasoning and common sense.

"We are shocked that the school district rules as they are written make no distinction between what Shelby is accused of and what a gang member does with a can of black spray paint,” Stu Sendelbach said.

The school administrators are simply foolish for sending young Miss Sendelbach off to an alternative school for four months for her misuse of a magic market, and their fall back for applying this punishment, “just following a state law,” exhibits the same lack of judgment young Miss Sendelbach exhibited when she penned her enamoration of Alex on the school wall.

A more reasoned punishment for young Miss Sendelbach would have seen her scrubbing her love missive off the wall, followed by applying a new coat of paint.

As for young Miss Sendelbach’s father’s assertion that the punishment applied to her is reasonable for a gang member with a can of black spray paint, but not to his daughter, exhibits the same lack of reasoning and common sense that the school administrators exhibited.  The same reasoned punishment I mention above for Miss Sendelbach, should be applied to any kid defacing a school wall, whether they’re a gang member or a little twelve year old girl.

School rates ‘I love Alex’ graffiti as bad as drugs, suspends 6th-grader for 4 months

Posted by on 07/08 at 06:45 AM

  1. While I understand your response, John, and I am sympathetic, I’m going to be a little less kind on the topic than are you.

    After dealing with government school teachers for most of my life, I’ve become firmly convinced this is not a situation of administration teachers being relieved of their reasoning skills and their common sense. Rather I suspect that such rules were set up in the first place, because such people possessed no reasoning skills, no common sense, to begin with.

    The particularly reasonless, the particularly senseless, end up being college professors. Usually , these end up in tenured positions. Erb, as an example. But thereby hangs a whole ‘nother thread, huh?

    And why he should our magic marker wielding twelve year old, be expected to possess any amounts of either reasoning skills or common sense, when the pablum she’s been force fed for the last six and a half years or so, has been absolutely devoid of it? What we’re seeing here, is the result, not the cause. GIGO. Follow?

    Posted by Bithead  on  07/08  at  01:23 PM

  2. Bithead,

    I understand, completely.

    Posted by John Venlet  on  07/08  at  01:56 PM

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Smileys

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below:


Next entry: Smoking Ban Effects

Previous entry: Handicapped by Roosevelt

<< Back to main